USDA, RMRS, AWAE logo USDA RMRS AWAE RMRS
  • ABOUT W&W
    • About Us
    • Scientist Profiles
  • RESEARCH
    • Aquatic Ecology
    • Atmospheric Sciences
    • Biogeochemistry
    • Climate Change
    • Engineering
    • Fire & Fuels
    • Fisheries
    • Geomorphology
    • Hydrology
    • Invasive Species
    • Plant Physiology
    • Sediment & Erosion
    • Spatial Analysis
    • Watershed Processes
  • PROJECTS, TOOLS, & DATA
    • Click for Complete List of W&W Projects, Tools, & Data
    • The Aquatic eDNAtlas Project
      • eDNAtlas Sample Results
      • Supporting Science
      • FAQ & Field Protocol
      • eDNA Sampling Grid
      • Project Background
      • Contacts
    • Bull Trout eDNA Project
      • eDNA Sampling & Supporting Science
      • Participating in the Bull Trout eDNA Survey
      • Bull Trout eDNA Sample Sites
      • The Status of the Bull Trout Survey
      • Partners
    • Cold-Water Climate Shield
      • Presentations & Publications
      • Digital Maps & ArcGIS Shapefiles
      • Data Sources & Documentation
      • Trout Distribution Monitoring
      • Related Links
        • NorWeST: Regional Database & Modeled Stream Temperature
        • SSN & STARS
        • Stream Temperature Monitoring & Modeling
        • U.S. Stream Flow Metric Dataset
    • Fire & Aquatic Ecosystems
      • Management Questions
      • Publications
        • Manuscripts & Reports
        • Fire & Aquatic Bibliography
        • Science Briefings
          • Adaptation for Wildland Aquatic Resources
          • Climate Change & Wildfires
          • Wildfire Impacts on Stream Sedimentation
      • Workshops
        • 2009
          • Agenda
          • Topics & Contacts
        • 2002
          • Author Profiles
          • Special Issue in Forest Ecology and Management
          • Downloadable Papers
      • Links
      • Photo Gallery
    • Geomorphic Road Analysis & Inventory Package (GRAIP)
      • Introduction
      • Case Studies
        • Legacy Roads
        • Watershed Studies
      • Publications
        • Manuals
        • Selected Articles
        • Science Briefings
        • Posters
      • Downloads & Software
        • GRAIP Source Code
        • Database Update (2013)
        • Data Dictionary 5.0
        • Terrain Analysis (TauDEM)
        • SINMAP 2
      • Supporting Information
        • Calculating Base Rate
        • List of Equipment
      • Photo Galleries
        • GRAIP
        • Legacy Roads
        • Other Roads
      • Links & Models
        • FishXing
        • WEPP
        • SEDMODL2
        • STREAM TEAM
        • Water-Road Interaction Technology Series
      • Training Opportunities
      • Jobs & Summer Employment
      • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Contacts
    • GRAIP_Lite
      • Manuals & Publications
      • GRAIP_Lite FAQs
      • Training Opportunities
      • Contacts
      • GRAIP_Lite Download
      • Case Studies
      • Managing Arid and Semi-Arid Watersheds
        • about
        • basics
        • bibliography
        • bibliography - supplemental
        • credits
        • data policy
        • U.S. LTER Watershed Sites
        • history
        • links
        • web resources
      • National Stream Internet
        • Workshops and Presentations
        • NSI Hydrography Network
        • Databases of Stream Reach Descriptors
        • Databases of Stream Measurements
        • SSN Bibliography
      • NorWeST: Regional Database & Modeled Stream Temperature
      • Project Boundary
      • Processing Status
      • Data Downloads
        • Stream Temperature Database
        • Modeled Stream Temperatures
      • Interactive Map
      • Publications
        • Supporting Research
        • Science Briefings
        • Posters & Presentations
        • Blogs & Newsletters
      • Supporting Information
        • Reconditioned NHD Plus
        • Regional Climate Downscaling
        • Climate-Aquatics Blog
        • 2011 Climate-Aquatics Decision Support Workshop
      • Related Links
        • SSN & STARS
        • Stream Temperature Monitoring & Modeling
        • U.S. Stream Flow Metric Dataset
      • Contacts & Contributors
    • Sediment Transport
      • Idaho & Nevada
        • Publications
        • FAQ & Contact Us
      • Colorado & Wyoming
        • Publications
        • FAQ & Contact Us
    • Spatial Statistical Modeling of Streams (SSN & STARS)
      • Frequently Asked Questions
      • Software & Data
      • GIS Layers
      • Publications & Presentations
      • Latest Releases
      • Authors & Contacts
      • Other Software
      • News
    • Stream Temperature Monitoring & Modeling
      • Protocols and Resources
      • Interactive Maps
      • Modeling
        • Air Temperature Model
        • Multiple Regression Model
        • Spatial Statistical Model
        • SSN & STARS
        • NorWeST
      • Resources
        • Climate Change Resource Center
        • Climate-Aquatics Blog
        • Climate-Aquatics Workshop
        • Temperature Data Macro
      • Publications
        • Publications & Presentations
        • Science Briefings
    • Understanding the diversity of Cottus in western North America
      • Current Contributions
      • Collection Particulars
      • Species of Interest
      • Phylogeography and Maps
      • Publications and Posters
      • Briefing Papers
      • Contact
    • Valley Bottom Confinement
      • Download VCA Script & Toolbox
      • Publications
    • Water Erosion Prediction Project (WEPP)
      • Forest Management
        • Disturbed WEPP
        • Disturbed WEPP Batch
        • ERMiT
        • ERMiT Batch
        • WEPP FuME
        • Tahoe Basin Sediment Model
      • Road Erosion
        • WEPP: Road
        • WEPP: Road Batch
      • Fire Effects
        • Disturbed WEPP
        • Disturbed WEPP Batch
        • ERMiT
        • ERMiT Batch
        • WEPP FuME
      • WEPP Climate Parameter Files
        • Rock:Clime
      • Peak Flow Calculator
      • Additional WEPP Resources
    • U.S. Stream Flow Metric Dataset
      • Dataset Downloads
      • Publications
        • Macroscale Hydrologic Modeling
        • Comparison of VIC/MC1 Models to Observed Gage Data
        • Science Briefing
      • Contacts
        • Charlie Luce
        • Seth Wenger
      • Links
        • NHD Plus
        • University of Washington Climate Impacts Group
        • Trout Unlimited Science Page
        • Climate-Aquatics Blog
      • Related Websites
        • SSN & STARS
        • Reconditioned NHD Plus
        • NorWeST Stream Temperature
        • Stream Temperature Modeling & Monitoring
  • PUBLICATIONS
    • Search Publications (TreeSearch)
    • Recent W&W Publications
    • All Available W&W Publications
    • Publications by Project or Research Subject
      • Biogeochemistry
      • Environmental DNA
      • Climate Change
      • Engineering
      • Fire & Aquatic Ecosystems
      • Geomorphic Road Analysis & Inventory Package (GRAIP)
      • Glacier Lakes Ecosystem Experiments Site (GLEES)
      • Invasive Aquatic Species
      • NorWeST Stream Temperature Regional Database & Model
      • River Bathymetry Toolkit (RBT)
      • Sediment Transport
        • Idaho/Nevada
        • Colorado/Wyoming
      • Spatial Statistical Modeling of Stream Networks (SSN & STARS)
      • Stream Temperature Modeling & Monitoring
      • Threats Assessment for Western Riparian Ecosystems
    • Science Briefings
      • Search by Title
      • Search by Researcher
      • Search by Subject
    • General Technical Reports
      • Search by Title
      • Search by Researcher
      • Search by Subject
  • CONTACT US
    • Locations
      • Albuquerque Forestry Sciences Lab
      • Boise Aquatic Sciences Lab
      • Flagstaff Forestry Sciences Lab
      • Fort Collins Biogeochemistry Lab
      • Fort Collins Forestry Sciences Lab
      • Missoula Fire Sciences Lab
      • Moscow Forestry Sciences Lab
    • Employee Profiles
    • Jobs & Employment
    • Website Feedback
    search only AWAE
Home Flagstaff Lab Managing Arid and Semi-Arid Watersheds Central Arizona Highlands Watershed Management Research
 

Watershed Management Research

Experimental Manipulation

Experimental manipulation is a research approach that has been used extensively in watershed research. A number of whole watershed treatments have been conducted to test research hypotheses, to obtain quantitative information on pertinent environmental issues, and to validate process-related formulations used in simulation models.

Paired watershed Method—A paired watershed methodology was used to evaluate treatment response. Two watersheds with similar characteristics (e.g., size, vegetation, precipitation, and soil type) were selected and before any watershed manipulation was done, runoff from each watershed was measured for several years to determine streamflow variations under pretreatment conditions. The number of years required depends on year to year variability normally experienced. In the semi-arid southwestern United States, it usually take about 7 years of pretreatment calibration to define a pretreatment relationship. During this time, the quantity and quality of other natural resources were also inventoried (e.g., soil loss, forage production, animal types and populations). One of the watersheds was designated to be the untreated or "control" watershed and the other watershed has a particular treatment applied to it.

Treated and Control Watersheds—With pretreatment measurements completed, one of the watersheds was designated to be the untreated or "control" watershed. The control watershed was shown to respond to environmental influences (pretreatment water yield regression) in a particular manner to the watershed where the experimental manipulation or treatment was to be applied.

Measurements continued on both the experimental and control watersheds for several years after a treatment was applied. Streamflow, sediment production, and water quality were monitored regularly, and other resources were reinventoried periodically. Changes caused by the management practice applied to the experimental unit were evaluated by comparing posttreatment values to the pretreatment data relationships.

Matter is Not Created or Destroyed—The physical law of continuity stated simply is that "matter is neither created or destroyed". A given environment or ecosystem over a period of time receives an average input of precipitation and produces an average output of streamflow. The difference between these two amounts is basically what is used by the vegetation growing on the site. Because matter or in this example precipitation is neither created or destroyed, if one can change the amount of water used by the vegetation there will be more water available for streamflow or percolation into the soil. Therefore, the key to increasing water yield is the replacement of deep-rooted or high water using plants with shallow-rooted or low water using plants.

Differences in water use by shallow and deep rooted plants
Differences in water use by shallow and deep rooted plants

Water Budget

Of the average 23.4 million ha-m (190 million acre-ft, 14.2 area inches, or 360 mm) of rain and snow that fall each year on the Colorado River Basin, in which the Arizona experimental watersheds lies, more than 90 % of it evaporates or is used by plants (Hibbert 1979). With such large amounts of water being returned to the atmosphere, even a slight reduction in this loss would leave substantially more water available for streamflow. As an example, if evapotranspiration over the entire Colorado River Basin could be reduced by only 1 %, the surface water supply would increase on the average by 0.2 million ha-m (1.75 million acre-ft) annually. However, the opportunity to significantly reduce evapotranspiration by management of vegetation and snow is limited to certain vegetation types.

Annual water budget for Arizona
Annual water budget for Arizona

Water Yield Opportunities—Water yield improvement, as it pertains to forest and rangelands, is based on the premise that streamflow and/or ground water are increased by an amount equal to the net reduction in evapotranspiration (Hibbert 1979). According to Hibbert, little opportunity exists to reduce transpiration where precipitation is less than about 460 mm(18 inches) (Figure from Hibbert) and is exceeded by potential evapotranspiration (warm, dry portions in figure ), because precipitation does not penetrate far into the soil, and one cover type is about as efficient as another in using the available water. The greatest opportunity to increase runoff by reducing transpiration exists where precipitation exceeds 460 mm (18 inches) and potential evapotranspiration (determined by the Thornthwaite method) exceeds 380 mm (15 inches). This kind of climate promotes vigorous growth of vegetation capable of using large amounts of water. Therefore, modifying plant cover under these conditions can substantially increase water yield.

Vegetation and Snow Management—Vegetation can be managed in several ways to reduce evapotranspiration:

  • Decrease stand density by various practices to reduce transpiration and interception.
  • Convert plant cover from one cover type to another that uses less water (type conversion).
  • Create openings in forest cover to reduce transpiration and to redistribute snow, thus concentrating the snow to reduce evaporation, to increase snowmelt efficiency, and to enhance contributions to streamflow.
  • Establish trees, large shrubs, or fences in windswept, treeless areas to pile snow in large drifts, thereby reducing evaporation losses from the snow.

The best opportunity to increase water yield by snow management is in cold climates where blowing snow can be concentrated in forest openings or trapped in large drifts to reduce evapotranspiration and to reduce losses to sublimation.

 

Find W&W and follow us on your favorite social media site:

facebook
twitter
youtube
email


  |  RMRS Home  |   AWAE Home  |   Disclaimers  |   Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)  |   Privacy Notice  |   Quality of Information  |   Print This Page  |