Rocky Mountain Research Station Publications

RMRS Online Publication - Journal Articles, External Publications, and Special Reports
Ethical implications of democratic theory for U.S. public participation in environmental impact assessment


Hourdequin, Marion; Landres, Peter; Hanson, Mark J.; Craig, David R. 2012. Ethical implications of democratic theory for U.S. public participation in environmental impact assessment. Environmental Impact Assessment Review. 35: 37-44.

doi: 10.1016/j.eiar.2012.02.001

Traditional mechanisms for public participation in environmental impact assessment under U.S. federal law have been criticized as ineffective and unable to resolve conflict. As these mechanisms are modified and new approaches developed, we argue that participation should be designed and evaluated not only on practical grounds of cost-effectiveness and efficiency, but also on ethical grounds based on democratic ideals. In this paper, we review and synthesize modern democratic theory to develop and justify four ethical principles for public participation: equal opportunity to participate, equal access to information, genuine deliberation, and shared commitment. We then explore several tensions that are inherent in applying these ethical principles to public participation in EIA. We next examine traditional NEPA processes and newer collaborative approaches in light of these principles. Finally, we explore the circumstances that argue for more in-depth participatory processes. While improved EIA participatory processes do not guarantee improved outcomes in environmentalmanagement, processes informed by these four ethical principles derived fromdemocratic theory may lead to increased public engagement and satisfaction with government agency decisions.

Keywords: ethics, democratic theory, public participation, NEPA, collaboration


About PDFs: For best results, do not open the PDF in your Web browser. Right-click on the PDF link to download the PDF file directly to your computer. Click here for more PDF help.


Download Article
http://www.fs.fed.us/rm/pubs_other/rmrs_2012_hourdequin_m001.pdf

PDF File Size: 265 K


Title: RMRS Other Publications: Ethical implications of democratic theory for U.S. public participation in environmental impact assessment
Electronic Publish Date: August 1, 2012
Last Update:
August 1, 2012

RMRS Publications | Order a publication | Contact Us