Rocky Mountain Research Station Publications
RMRS Online Publication - Journal
Articles, External Publications, and Special Reports
Tradeoffs in overstory and understory aboveground net primary productivity in southwestern ponderosa pine stands
Sabo, Kyla E.; Hart, Stephen C.; Sieg, Carolyn Hull; Bailey, John Duff. 2008. Tradeoffs in overstory and understory aboveground net primary productivity in southwestern ponderosa pine stands. Forest Science. 54(4): 408-416.
Previous studies in ponderosa pine forests have quantified the relationship between overstory stand characteristics and understory production using tree measurements such as basal area. We built on these past studies by evaluating the tradeoff between overstory and understory aboveground net primary productivity (ANPP) in southwestern ponderosa pine forests at the landscape level and over a gradient of stand structural types and burn histories. We measured overstory and understory attributes in 2004 and 2005 in four stand structural types (unmanaged, thinned, thinned and burned, and low basal area thinned and burned) relative to a stand-replacing wildfire site. Thinning alone and with prescribed burning reduced stand-level wood and total tree production relative to unmanaged stands. Understory (herbaceous) ANPP was highest in wildfire stands and low basal area thinned and burned plots but did not differ among the other stand structural types, apparently because of high residual basal area and relatively uniform tree spacing. Contemporary ponderosa pine forests are low productivity ecosystems that exhibit a threshold response between reductions in tree density and increases in understory production at ~5.9 m2 ha. We calculated the slope of the relationship between tree and herbaceous ANPP to be -0.14, which was lower than the values we estimated from other, more productive savanna ecosystems. Our results suggest that to maintain more fire-resistant and hence sustainable southwestern ponderosa pine ecosystems, tree densities need to be substantially reduced from contemporary levels. Large, landscape-level reductions in tree density will decrease total ecosystem production of this forest type, but this reduction will probably be small relative to ecosystem production losses after widespread, stand-replacing wildfires.
Keywords: aboveground tree production, aboveground understory production, basal area, thinning and prescribed burning, northern Arizona
About PDFs: For best results, do not open the PDF in your Web browser. Right-click on the PDF link to download the PDF file directly to your computer. Click here for more PDF help.
PDF File Size: 360 K
Title: RMRS Other
Publications: Tradeoffs in overstory and understory aboveground
net primary productivity in southwestern ponderosa pine stands
Electronic Publish Date: January 12, 2009
Last Update: January 12, 2009
RMRS Publications | Order a publication | Contact Us